Posted on 31 July 2019

As congestion in cities rises, existing transportation can no longer keep up with growing populations. In 2018, UK drivers lost an average of 178 hours a year due to congestion, costing an average of £1,317 per driver. As a result, micromobility solutions are gaining popularity in cities around the world, as people seek alternative methods of transportation in a new era of future mobility.   

Starting over a decade ago as a micromobility solution intended to cover the last mile of one’s trip, bike sharing has now moved into the new age of future mobility. The hype around e-scooters, originating from tech cities in the US like San Francisco, has reached European shores. Over the last year, micromobility providers started to appear all over Europe, with some cities seeing not one or two but four or more different providers swamping the streets with their rides. While diversity and choice certainly furthers rapid adoption, how many providers are simply too many? In San Francisco for example, this oversupply lead to new legislation requiring scooter companies to obtain a license. Only two such licenses were subsequently issued.

The situation in Europe

In a bid to combat growing urban transportation demands, many European cities have begun to introduce e-scooters. In Germany, law makers recently voted to allow e-scooters to take to the streets, with rides already appearing in the inner cities of Munich and Hamburg. While many welcome this decision, German cycling association, ADFC, believes there to be a lack of infrastructure, highlighting cyclists will now require additional space.

Meanwhile, France recently hardened its stance against e-scooters following a multitude of e-scooter related accidents, and one death. The Ministries of the Interior and Transport outlined new rules to come into force in September 2019, including limiting e-scooters to a speed of 25 kilometres per hour and banning their use on pavements. With the list of safety concerns growing, regulatory reviews in other countries are also increasingly likely.

Furthermore, the swift introduction of e-scooters in Europe not only raises safety concerns, but has also potentially come at the expense of brands building and protecting their core intellectual property (IP), as they are still not legal in key European markets, such as the Netherlands and the UK.

Is this business model sustainable?

With multiple providers swamping Europe, Tony Ho, Vice-President of Global Business Development at Segway-Ninebot, says “The standalone business model, I think it is questionable whether it’s self-sustainable”. From a user perspective, too many different providers certainly isn’t ideal either, each requiring a dedicated app with individual registration and submission of payment details. A more centralized solution would clearly be favourable, if only for data privacy reasons. Uber and Lyft are already providing e-scooters from within their apps. In Europe, ShareNow, the shared mobility consortium of BMW, Daimler and myTaxi, is planning to introduce their Lisbon experiment “Hive” across Europe, presumably also from within their app ShareNow. The coming months certainly will be exciting times and it remains to be seen, which company can secure the biggest market share with the most reliable, simple, user friendly, and most private of solutions.

Despite an increasing amount of contenders entering the market, it is still early days for micromobility. Further regulations are likely as we continue to adapt to the introduction of transportation alternatives such as e-scooters, while the business model is also yet to proven sustainable. What is clear is that this area of future mobility is becoming an increasingly exciting space, and does not look to be slowing down. 

Read more about future mobility
Autonomous driving: the IP twists and turns

Self-driving vehicles: what do consumers think (and want)?
Autonomous vehicles - the race to innovate
The road to autonomous
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles: growth and innovation
A single to Singapore please: the rise in on-demand bus services
The journey of rLoop - a new technology innovation network disrupting the world of transport and IP
Data and security issues in a world of connected cars

Mewburn Ellis are experts in obtaining patent protection in the field of future mobility, with a diverse line-up of experienced intellectual property professionals forming a dedicated future mobility team. 

Speak to a member of the future mobility team

Christoph Moeller

Contact Christoph Moeller

Christoph is spearheading our dedicated team of future mobility experts. He has previously worked for different global players in the transportation sector, in the automotive and aerospace field. His background in electronics and engineering, and in particular his previous involvement in IT, computer software and telecommunications matters, means he is well versed in assisting companies in the future mobility sector with the various challenges they face. Christoph is located in our Munich Office and is a German Patent Attorney and a European Patent Attorney and holds two Master of Laws Degrees. Besides attending to patent matters in our engineering practice group before the German Patent and Trade Mark Office and the European Patent Offices as well as the German Patent Courts and the Higher Regional Courts, he is involved in our design practice. Due to his previous position as head of patents of a globally operating Swiss Engineering Company, he also advises on all matters of IP strategy.

Related Posts